I found adding the "Security" Folder and these settings to my registry fixed my issue. From this article:
https://knowledge.digicert.com/solution/timestamp-vba-projects

Computer\HKEY_CURRENT_USER\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\VBA\Security

Registry settings:

*If the above folder does not exist, manually go to the VBA folder, right click, and add a new key called Security

(STRING VALUE) Name: TimeStampURL Value: http://timestamp.digicert.com

(DWORD) Name: TimeStampRetryCount Value: 3

(DWORD) Name: TimeStampRetryDelay Value: 5

(DWORD) Name: V1HashEnhanced Value: 3