Today is a new day and my brain is refreshed, a-new.
I had 2 problems. Fires, I forgot to set apache2 as owner of website 2's default index.html file. When apache2 didn't find anything to return, it moved on to display my other website.
Second of all, I attempted to sign my 2nd site with my first site's credentials. This may have contributed to this issue of Mal-performance.