79755392

Date: 2025-09-04 07:28:55
Score: 0.5
Natty:
Report link

Great questions! You're asking all the right things as someone starting with container orchestration. Let me break this down clearly:

Minikube vs Multi-Node Clusters

You're absolutely right - Minikube is single-node only. It's designed to run Kubernetes locally on your laptop for learning/development. For your 4-node Raspberry Pi cluster, Minikube won't work.

For Raspberry Pi clusters, you have better options:

Docker Compose Multi-Host Question

Docker Compose alone cannot manage containers across different hosts. It's designed for single-host deployments. If you want to run containers on multiple Raspberry Pis with Docker Compose, you'd need separate compose files on each Pi - no automatic coordination between them.

For simple cross-host orchestration, you'd need something like Docker Swarm or K3s.

Docker Swarm vs Kubernetes

They're completely independent solutions that solve the same problem:

You pick one or the other, not both.

Kubernetes on Raspberry Pi - Resource Usage

You heard correctly! Full Kubernetes is resource-hungry on Pi. A single-node Kubernetes cluster can easily consume 1GB+ RAM just for the control plane components, leaving little for your actual applications.

This is why I strongly recommend K3s for Raspberry Pi clusters.

K3s - Perfect for Raspberry Pi

K3s is lightweight Kubernetes that's perfect for your use case:

Setup Recommendation for Your 4-Pi Cluster

On your main Pi (master node):

curl -sfL https://get.k3s.io | sh -

On the other 3 Pis (worker nodes):

curl -sfL https://get.k3s.io | K3S_URL=https://main-pi-ip:6443 K3S_TOKEN=your-token sh -

Alternative: Docker Swarm for Simplicity

If K3s feels too complex initially, Docker Swarm is simpler:

On main Pi:

docker swarm init

On other Pis:

docker swarm join --token :2377

Then you can deploy with docker stack deploy using compose files.

My Recommendation Path:

  1. Start with Docker Swarm - easier to understand, good for learning clustering concepts
  2. Move to K3s when you want more advanced features
  3. Never use full Kubernetes on Pi - it's overkill and will eat your resources

Quick Comparison for Pi Clusters:

Tool RAM Usage Complexity Pi Suitable
Docker Compose Low Very Low Single Pi only
Docker Swarm Low Low ✅ Great
K3s Low Medium ✅ Excellent
Full Kubernetes High High ❌ Too heavy
MicroK8s Medium Medium ✅ Good

Start with K3s - it's specifically designed for scenarios like yours and will give you the best learning experience without killing your Pi's performance.


For a detailed comparison of lightweight Kubernetes options perfect for Pi clusters, check out: https://toolstac.com/alternatives/kubernetes/lightweight-orchestration-alternatives/lightweight-alternatives

Reasons:
  • Long answer (-1):
  • No code block (0.5):
  • Low reputation (1):
Posted by: Travis Savo