The issue was ultimately the workflow steps and not getting all the session keys properly set. When clicking on Sign In Button, you go to https://auth.pff.com. I tried going directly to https://auth.pff.com. However, when adjusting and going to https://premium.pff.com and clicking on "sign in" button, everything populated correctly. For some reason the Session key for "loggedIn" was not getting set to True otherwise.

I did have to add 1-2 second sleep as well to make sure the Captcha Loaded... no interaction with it, but you just had to let it load.